This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Quick Verdict
One good coat and I’m ready to go. That’s the whole pitch for this curl mascara, and after using it a few times it’s true. The bendy narrow wand gets me closer to my lash line for a natural yet still dramatic lift, without me having to fuss over it.
Buy if you:
- Want one-coat lift for a fast morning routine
- Like a slim, bendy wand that reaches the lash root
- Want natural-but-dramatic, not clumpy spider lashes
- Shop vegan and cruelty-free drugstore beauty
Skip if you:
- Want a huge, thick brush that fans out lashes fast (this one’s slim and narrow)
- Need a specific waterproof or brown formula (I used the pitch black)
- Prefer heavy false-lash drama from a single coat with zero building
Clicking takes you to Amazon. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases — pricing and availability subject to change.
| Product | e.l.f. Incredi-Curl Mascara |
|---|---|
| Shade tested | Pitch Black |
| Brush | Curved, double-sided bristle wand |
| Formula | Buildable, smudge- flake- and transfer-resistant |
| Ethics | Vegan, double-certified cruelty-free (Leaping Bunny & PETA) |
One Coat And I’m Ready To Go
I’ve cycled through enough mascaras to know what I’m comparing it to, and the e.l.f. Incredi-Curl is the one I keep reaching for. Not because it does something miraculous, because it does exactly what I need in a single pass and doesn’t make me think about it again. You can check the current price on Amazon here if you want to see where it’s landing today.
If you’re shopping for a curl mascara that gives you lift without a whole production every morning, this is the lane it lives in. One good coat and I’m out the door. And on the days I want more, it builds.
The Bendy Narrow Wand Is The Whole Story
The wand has a little bit of a bend to it, and that’s my favorite thing about it. It’s long and narrow, which is always what I want, because I just find I can get closer to my actual eye or eyelid. Getting close to the base of the lashes is what lets me lift and separate them better.
It’s a curved, double-sided bristle brush. e.l.f. designed it so the inner curve sits at the base of your lashes and the outer curve layers on extra coats. The shade I’ve been using is Pitch Black. The formula is meant to be smudge-, flake- and transfer-resistant, and it’s vegan and double-certified cruelty-free by Leaping Bunny and PETA, which matters to me.
Natural Yet Still Dramatic, In One Pass
I applied it to one eye on camera and had to glance away from the lens to actually see what I was doing, the wand moved that fast from root to tip without dragging or clumping. By the time I looked back at the lens, the lashes were already lifted and separated.
What it gives me is a very nice natural yet still dramatic look. Not clumpy, not spidery, just lifted and separated. When I did the second eye I ended up taking that side out a little too, so both matched. But look at that. One good coat and it’s done.
Add A Second Coat For Evening
If I wanted more drama, I’d just add a second coat. Say I’m going out in the evening, I layer it on again with the outer curve of the wand and turn the volume up. That’s the buildable part working the way it’s supposed to. During the day, though, one coat is plenty for me.
The Slim Wand Cuts Both Ways
The narrow wand is the reason I like this mascara, and it’s also the one thing worth knowing before you buy. Because it’s slim and long rather than big and fluffy, it’s not the fastest brush for piling on instant thickness. If you’re used to a fat, dense brush that coats everything in one swipe, this asks you to be a little more deliberate. I wiggle it up from the root, and on my second eye I had to go back and even things out so both sides matched. That’s not a complaint from me, I actually prefer the control. But if you want max volume with zero effort, the shape is the trade-off.
Get it now
Get the best price on Amazon →This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Who This Is Actually For
If your mascara routine is currently “wiggle, swipe, done,” this wand fits that exactly. Where it earns its place over a bigger brush is at the lash line, the slim tip gets close enough to the root that you’re lifting from the base, not just coating the tips and hoping for curl.
And if you shop your beauty with values in mind, it being vegan and cruelty-free with a drugstore price is a real plus. It lands under the price of a lot of the premium ones I’ve tried, and delivers the lift and separation I want.
Advice Before You Buy
Wiggle the wand up from the base in a zig-zag, don’t just drag it through the tips. That’s how you get the lift and how the curl sets. Use the inner curve first, then flip to the outer curve if you want that second evening coat.
The shade I used is Pitch Black. If you specifically want a brown or a waterproof version, check the listing options at the link before you add to cart, because I can only speak to the black one I tested. For everyday wear, one good coat is where I’d start. You can always see today’s price and shade options on Amazon.
Pros
- One good coat gives a natural yet still dramatic lift, no fuss
- Bendy, long, narrow wand gets close to the lash line to lift and separate
- Buildable, so a second coat turns it into evening drama
- Quick, smooth application
- Vegan and cruelty-free at a drugstore price
Cons
- Slim wand isn’t the fastest for instant heavy thickness
- I had to go back and even out my second eye so both sides matched
- I only tested the Pitch Black shade, so I can’t speak to brown or waterproof versions
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the e.l.f. Incredi-Curl Mascara come in a waterproof version?
I tested the standard Pitch Black formula, not a waterproof one. If a waterproof curl mascara is what you need, check the shade and formula options on the product page before ordering, since availability changes.
Is there a brown curl mascara option?
The one I used was pitch black. e.l.f. often lists more than one shade, so if you want a softer brown look, look at the color options at the link. I can only speak to the black version from my own use.
Does it smudge or flake during the day?
e.l.f. formulates this to be smudge-, flake- and transfer-resistant so you don’t get raccoon eyes by noon. In my own wear it held up fine through the day with one coat.
How many coats do I actually need?
One good coat is enough for a natural yet dramatic daytime look. If you’re going out in the evening, add a second coat using the outer curve of the wand to build more volume and curl.
Is the e.l.f. Incredi-Curl Mascara vegan and cruelty-free?
Yes. It’s proudly vegan and double-certified cruelty-free by Leaping Bunny and PETA. That’s part of why I like recommending it as a guilt-free drugstore pick.
Will the narrow wand work for short or sparse lashes?
The slim, bendy wand is well suited to shorter lashes because it gets close to the base and lifts from the root. That reach is exactly why I like it, since it separates rather than clumping.
How do I clean the wand and store the mascara?
Wipe the wand on a clean tissue if product builds up on the bristles, and keep the tube tightly closed so the formula doesn’t dry out. Like any mascara, replace it every few months once it starts to dry or smell off.
Is a drugstore curl mascara this cheap actually worth it over premium ones?
For me, yes. I’ve tried a bunch of different ones and this budget pick gives me the lift and separation I want in one coat. If you’re deciding between it and a pricier tube, the faster application and sharper lash line separation make it the better choice.
Get it now
e.l.f. Incredi-Curl Mascara
Get the best price on Amazon →This post contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
🛍️ Shop everything in this video
Every product mentioned, in one place — these are affiliate links, so I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
🛍️ E.L.F. Incredi-Curl Mascara — check price on Amazon →
